Renaming RESTful actions

I’ve got a RESTful controller that takes in a file upload as the main input into a table. I want to rename POST:resources_url to hit #upload instead of #create. Is there something I can specify on map.resources that allows me to do this? Or am I stuck generating a URL like “/resource/;upload” ?

Jason

A little more information, here’s my test (which is failing, difference being :action => ‘create’ is generated, not ‘upload’):

assert_recognizes({:controller => 'taxes', :action => 'upload'}, {:path => 'taxes', :method => :post})

and current routing

map.resources :taxes, :new => {:upload => :post}

Jason

Hi,

I know that the old routing is still available, I’m trying to stay away from it as much as I can. The problem I have with REST right now is that there is no “accepted spec” for doing REST, if that makes any sense. When it comes to controllers that are a little more complex than just serving up a view to a model, is it ok to drop out of REST? What is the point that a site is no-longer RESTful?

Jason

You have to be pragmatic. If the REST philosophy doesn't fit a
particular case, well, don't bother.

Hope that helps !

It does fit. All I’m trying to do is rename the action being used by the POST action (default create, I want to rename it to upload). Is this possible?

Jason

Hi Jason,

Earlier on you said: Or am I stuck generating a URL like “/resource/;upload”

Forgive me if I’m being dense, but why do you want he default POST to call a method called update() rather than create()? It seems to me that if you want POST /some/url to perform a specific set of actions, why wouldn’t you just do those actions in create rather than fight the framework?

Or, are you in fact saying that you want to have two urls to create a resource in your :taxes resource collection: one that calls create() and another that calls upload()?

If so, have you tried:

map.resources :taxes, :collection => {:upload => :post}

However, that most definitely does generate a resource url like /taxes;upload so it may not be what you’re looking for.

Regards,

Trevor

One thing I had to let go of when I started using the RESTful methodology was the need to have my urls all styled looking with no parameters hanging out looking all ugly. Sometimes getting those params inline is a matter of rethinking things and nesting routes but sometimes you just have to raise up those hands and concede to the RESTy way. I’m still bugged by things like http://domain.com/users/1/entries;?page=2 but I’ve come to accept them [on my admin side*] as accurate representations of what is important and what is ephemeral/peripheral information. In this case, the fact that the data on page two isn’t necessarily the same every time is a good indicator that it’s not actually a resource itself and therefore just a hanging param. Perhaps your desire to rename “create” to “upload” without having to change its basic function is similar. :slight_smile:

RSL

*On my spiderable content side, I’ve heard that urls like http://domain.com/users/1/entries;?page=2 don’t get indexed and therefore aren’t perhaps the best way of arranging one’s archives. YMMV