Need help with ID-less legacy databases

I'm a newbie converting a large Foxpro database (188 MB) to Ruby on Rails (RoR) so we can get reports out of it. Our accounting service sends us weekly updates of the entire database. We don't enter any data (that's done at the accounting service). The biggest tables are Customers (now 15,000 rows, 2.5 MB) and Transactions (525K rows, 112 MB). Each of the Foxpro tables has its own key field, which is quite different from RoR's autoincrementing inntegers.

For example, the Foxpro Customers table is indexed by Account Number, a 5-digit string that ranges from '00001' to '15221'. So it's almost the same as an ID field, but not quite.

I have it running using a standard RoR setup including the usual autoincrementing ID fields. Right now, before loading new data, I do a Customer.delete_all and then import using the superb DBF Ruby gem. Ditto the Transactions table (I call it Xactions so as not to confuse it with the transaction method). Each time I do this, the table starts incrementing the IDs from where it left off. So the second time I load Customers it starts with ID 15222, the third time with 30487 (more customers), etc. Therefore, :id has no relationship with the Account Number. Moreover, in order to hook up the other tables with Customers, I have to go through each row, look up the account number, and find the associated :id. Given a database of this size, it takes HOURS. Worse, the problem with the Xactions table is we'll run out of :id numbers at some point (11 digits).

I tried using the Account Number string as the foreign key, but RoR REALLY wants an integer field and wouldn't accept it.

I thought I'd solve this by setting :id => false in the table migration and then adding a t.column :id :integer right afterwards. Then, when I load the data, I'd convert the Account Number string to the :id integer. Simple. Sweet.

The PROBLEM is that RoR has NO WAY to save or update data without an existing :id. As the Thomas/Hansson _Agile Web Development_ book makes clear, RoR just won't save anything in this situation.

I can think of several solutions: 1. Keep the existing setup and just load the data after hours. So what if it takes all night?

2. Delete the table and then recreate it, so the :id of the reloaded table starts at 1. I don't know how to do this programmatically. Is there another way to reset the :id counter without deleting the table?

3. Doing the shortcut with MySQL would be a piece of cake, but I don't know the syntax to save or update a record in an ActiveRecord context behind RoR's back.

Any suggestions? ---Jim Gagne---

Hi Nic,

something like this should do the trick, it's in the MySQL manual (MySQL :: MySQL 8.0 Reference Manual :: 13.1.20 CREATE TABLE Statement)…

CREATE TABLE rails_customers (   SERIAL id, ... ) SELECT * FROM customers;

I don't think that you can takeover the provided IDs, you can store it in another column.

If you can you maybe need to typecast the provided id in the SELECT statement with: SELECT UNSIGNED AS id, ... and replace: -SERIAL id +UNIQUE(id)

I only got PostgreSQL here so I can't test it, so be sure to test this within a transaction or even with a development db...

UPDATE, DELETE and SELECT should work w/o SERIAL id. If you want to create new rails_customers than you maybe need to set the id of the new record manually:

before_save :get_id def get_id   write_attribute :id, self.class.max(:id) + 1 end

You need to reserve the id somehow... don't know how...

Good luck Florian