Child validations?

Hi,

I'm working on my User model, which derives from Party, and parties have
many e-mail addresses, telephones, and mailing addresses. When I save
the user model, the validations occur, but the child error messages
appear to be summarized. I expected the child errors to be listed in
detail, as in "Put in the address, dummy". Instead, rails returns
"Emails is invalid", or "Addresses is Invalid" for the message.

In irb, I see that there are some interesting methods for the user
object:
validate_associated_records_for_emails
validate_associated_records_for_addresses
validate_associated_records_for_phones

They appear to add the child messages to the @errors object of the user
model, but they don't seem to be called by @user.save!

Also, I tried adding the following to the view, it didn't appear to
help:
<%= error_messages_for :address %>
<%= error_messages_for :email %>
<%= error_messages_for :phone %>

What is the rails way to force the display of the child errors? Or
perhaps more appropriately, what is the correct way to handle validation
when working with parent and child records on the same form.

Thank you!

app/models/party.rb
class Party < ActiveRecord::Base
  has_many :addresses
  has_many :emails
  has_many :phones
end

app/models/user.rb
Class User < Party
end

app/models/email.rb
class Email < ActiveRecord::Base
  belongs_to :party
  validates_presence_of :address, "Put in the address, dummy"
end

app/controllers/account_controller.rb
def signup
  @user = User.new
  @user.emails << Email.new
  @user.phones << Phone.new
  @user.addresses << Address.new
end

def signup_post
  @user = User.new(params[:user])
  params[:email].each {|e| @user.emails << Email.new(e)}
  params[:address].each {|a| @user.addresses << Address.new(a)}
  params[:phone].each {|t| @user.phones << Phone.new(t)}
  @user.save!
  flash[:notice] = "Thanks for signing up!"
rescue ActiveRecord::RecordInvalid
  render :action => 'signup'
end

Regards,
Rich

Duzenbury, Rich wrote:

I'm working on my User model, which derives from Party, and parties have
many e-mail addresses, telephones, and mailing addresses. When I save
the user model, the validations occur, but the child error messages
appear to be summarized. I expected the child errors to be listed in
detail, as in "Put in the address, dummy". Instead, rails returns
"Emails is invalid", or "Addresses is Invalid" for the message.

In irb, I see that there are some interesting methods for the user
object:
validate_associated_records_for_emails
validate_associated_records_for_addresses
validate_associated_records_for_phones

They appear to add the child messages to the @errors object of the user
model, but they don't seem to be called by @user.save!

Those built-in child validations will only be done for new
children, not for child updates. Use a validates_associated
declaration to fully control when child validity is checked.
You can then turn off the automatic validation by removing or
emptying the above methods.

Also, I tried adding the following to the view, it didn't appear to
help:
<%= error_messages_for :address %>
<%= error_messages_for :email %>
<%= error_messages_for :phone %>

What is the rails way to force the display of the child errors? Or
perhaps more appropriately, what is the correct way to handle validation
when working with parent and child records on the same form.

The most simple way to display all the errors:

<% for assn in [:addresses, :emails, :phones]
      for @obj in @user.send(assn) %>
        <%= error_messages_for :obj %>
<% end
    end %>