A copy of XX has been removed from the module tree but is still active!

I have a class in my /lib/ directory called tracker.rb

It's function is to receive an array of URLs and then perform 4 separate tasks on each URL

Each of the 4 tasks gets it's own thread.

the class is called from my controller like:

output = Tracker.go([array_of_urls])

Sometimes, when it hits an exception, instead of just dieing gracefully, my logs repeatedly display:

A copy of Tracker has been removed from the module tree but is still active!

After this happens, I have to reboot my development server before it will respond again.

Any ideas how or why this is happening?

Many thanks in advance for your insight.

Some more information:

Usually, when I get this "A copy of Tracker has been removed from the module tree but is still active!" error, the exception raised is:

wrong status line: "A\353\307\351\245}\243Z\213\364\232\3117\203w? \axcnv\313\356\230v\350\345\f\346\032e\262\2148\002$hZ\3163\362'\373N+e \3306\005'\3555\241\016\340\364\351\022+\333\340F\b \372\274\244\357\004\212\241\026\325)6v\0056\t\374\017\023N% \352\214\207\267R_,\017e^\3321\327Gq\031! gG5\020\241\3565\356\200\3053\233\e\237\201\313\367\351/\327\206u.S \331z.\023\326'\2277\303\v\361\366a\270\304yf\376\315h \257\345A{\226\264\2352?\365\335\001_Hl:F\2429\322\250\320k\250\002k \315\332\200\226\027P\374\335\363&\344\201#t<\355\360.\331\365?(X=:5Y \240w6\365x\310\367\346\3368\315\350>W\370\034\377\351Uk\001iOW.=\300k \036\351\307\323\303N\315\243\240\326eu\375AP, \326\243\036\263\306\250\313\335\254hm/H\254L\251\212= \334\022\363\366\251W\251UK\227W\373\215E\346\223\3316\343\375 \a \336\347\224\355\224u\017\tq\006\364\v\334\346O\355\205s \317\031\202\260\322'v?\2303\022\210\0062\002\300j\212mo^\254R\334=? \275\331cu'\320G\216\021\353Sb\223\234\037\262\200s\367\a"

I have a class in my /lib/ directory called tracker.rb

It's function is to receive an array of URLs and then perform 4 separate tasks on each URL

Each of the 4 tasks gets it's own thread.

the class is called from my controller like:

output = Tracker.go([array_of_urls])

Sometimes, when it hits an exception, instead of just dieing gracefully, my logs repeatedly display:

I bet if you switched to production mode it would work. What I think
is happening is:

- request calls Tracker.go - Rails unloads loaded classes (since we're in dev mode) - You threads continue to run trying to use classes that rails has
unloaded. Chaos ensues.

Fred

Frederick Cheung wrote:

I bet if you switched to production mode it would work. What I think is happening is:

- request calls Tracker.go - Rails unloads loaded classes (since we're in dev mode) - You threads continue to run trying to use classes that rails has unloaded. Chaos ensues.

Fred

Bingo! Putting my application in production mode allowed me to make continual requests. It, however, doesn't solve the problem though.

Problem: I've got a module (AccessControl) in RAILS_ROOT/lib that extends my controllers (which inherit from ResourceController) and adds functionality to AuthenticatedSystem. In development mode, this works fine via requests through the browser. However, once I try to consume the resources with ActiveResource, the first request succeeds and the next request fails with the following error:

ArgumentError (A copy of AccessControl has been removed from the module tree but is still active!):     /opt/local/lib/ruby/gems/1.8/gems/activesupport-2.1.1/lib/active_support/dependencies.rb:250:in `load_missing_constant'     /opt/local/lib/ruby/gems/1.8/gems/activesupport-2.1.1/lib/active_support/dependencies.rb:468:in `const_missing'     /lib/access_control.rb:122:in `controller_target' ...

I can't figure out why this would work via the browser but not through ActiveResource. The only thing that's different, if I understand it correctly, are the headers:     Accept: application/xml     Content-Type: application/xml

Why would that make a difference? Not only that, the error is originating in the class it says it can't find. Does anyone understand why this might be the case?

Frederick Cheung wrote: > I bet if you switched to production mode it would work. What I think > is happening is:

> - request calls Tracker.go > - Rails unloads loaded classes (since we're in dev mode) > - You threads continue to run trying to use classes that rails has > unloaded. Chaos ensues.

> Fred

Bingo! Putting my application in production mode allowed me to make continual requests. It, however, doesn't solve the problem though.

The depedencies system has been confused: something is referencing an old copy of the module but that old copy should not be used anymore (since rails has reloaded a fresh copy). This can be caused by using require inappropriately (http://spacevatican.org/2008/9/28/required-or- not) or when things that shouldn't be reloaded are reloaded (this can be changed by adding files to Dependencies.load_once_paths (see also http://groups.google.com/group/rubyonrails-core/browse_thread/thread/710868b1292c737f/9e39c0716569a355?lnk=gst&q=module+tree#9e39c0716569a355). In your case I'd guess the latter - you're extending something like a plugin (which isn't reloaded between requests) with something that is reloaded between requests = trouble.

Fred

Sorry, forgot to mention. You need to restart the server after modifying the config file (and will have to restart it every time you make any changes to your classes, too).

A copy of Tracker has been removed from the module tree but is still active!

After this happens, I have to reboot my development server before it will respond again.

Any ideas how or why this is happening?

Appears that it can occur when a plugin [which isn't reloaded] keeps a reference to a normal class [which is reloaded].

ex: engines don't reload, normal app does, if there was any intermingling boom! http://groups.google.com/group/rubyonrails-core/browse_thread/thread/9067bce01444fb24#

"a copy of OrderHelper has been removed from the module tree"

I think that's what happens to me, anyway. So much for the usefulness of dev. mode :slight_smile:

-r