n:m relationship, joining table record creation issue

Hey all,

I have an n:m relationship between lpl_short_form_apps and practice_areas. The joining table is called practices. The definitions are as follows (minus validation/business logic):

LPLSFAs Model: class LPLShortFormApp < ActiveRecord::Base   has_many :practices   has_many :practice_areas, :through => :practices   has_many :attorneys end Table: class CreateLplShortFormApps < ActiveRecord::Migration   def self.up     create_table :lpl_short_form_apps do |t|       t.string :applicant_name, :null => false       t.string :principal_business_address       ...       t.string :email_address, :null => false       t.datetime :effective_date_requested       ...       t.timestamps     end   end

  def self.down     drop_table :lpl_short_form_apps   end end

Practice Areas Model: class PracticeArea < ActiveRecord::Base   has_many :practices   has_many :lpl_short_form_apps, :through => :practices end Table: class CreatePracticeAreas < ActiveRecord::Migration   def self.up     create_table :practice_areas do |t|       t.string :area       t.integer :specialty

      t.timestamps     end   end

  def self.down     drop_table :practice_areas   end end

Model: class Practice < ActiveRecord::Base   belongs_to :lpl_short_form_app, :class_name => "LPLShortFormApp"   belongs_to :practice_areas end Table: class Practices < ActiveRecord::Migration   def self.up     create_table :practices, :id => false do |t|       t.integer :lplsfa_id, :null => false, :options => "CONSTRAINT fk_practices_lplsfas REFERENCES lpl_short_form_apps(id)"       t.integer :practice_area_id, :null => false, :options => "CONSTRAINT fk_practices_areas_of_practice REFERENCES practice_area (id)"

      t.decimal :percentage, :null => false     end   end

  def self.down     drop_table :practices   end end

I think that's the proper way to setup the relationships. If it isn't, can someone guide me along the right method?

What I want to do, what I'm having an issue doing, is generating the new records in the n:m relationship. By business rules, we have 30 Practice Areas set up. Each LPLSFA can have a percentage of those areas up to 100%; so, I have a practices_controller defined with an index that generates a form with all of the areas of practice and a percentage field.

This is the controller code:   def index     @lpl_short_form_app = LPLShortFormApp.find(session [:lplsfa_id])     @practice = Practice.new     @practice_areas = PracticeArea.all     respond_to do |format|       format.html # index.html.erb       format.xml { render :xml => @practice }     end   end

This is the index page: <div class = "demo-long-form">   <% form_for(@practice) do |f| %>   <%= f.error_messages %>   <fieldset>     <legend>Listing all Areas of Practice for <%= @lpl_short_form_app.applicant_name %></legend>     <% @practice_areas.each do |practice_area| %>     <div>       <%= f.label practice_area.area %>       <%= f.text_field :percentage, :id => practice_area.area %>     </div>     <% end %>     <div>       <%= f.submit 'Set' %>     </div>   </fieldset>   <% end %> </div>

So, my questions are as follows: 1. How do I have the submit button go to the "Set" action defined in the practices_controller? 2. How do I collect/scrape each of the individual percentages from the form so that I can validate them against a total of 100%? 3. How do I take that collection and generate a new record in the practices table such that it joins the LPLSFA with the Practice Area? Each LPLSFA will have all 30 practice areas, so 30 practices records, most of which will probably be at a 0 percentage. I'm imagining something like this:

  def set     @practice_areas = PracticeArea.all     @lpl_short_form_app = LPLShortFormApp.find(session[:lplsfa_id])     @practice_areas.each do |practice_area|       @practice_areas.lpl_short_form_apps << @lpl_short_form_app     end   end

I know this is a long message, but I hope it gets a fair evaluation. It breaks down to my lack of understanding of many to many relationships in Ruby, my lack of understanding of the form_for in Rails, and my lack of understanding of both ruby/rails general syntax. I have the Ruby 1.9 Pickaxe book as well as the Agile Web Dev with Rail, 3rd ed. but having read through the beginning sections of both books hasn't cleared this up for me.

So, my questions are as follows: 1. How do I have the submit button go to the "Set" action defined in the practices_controller?

by default this form would submit to the update (if the record existed) or create (if it didn't) url for that practice - which doesn;t sound quite right - the model you are editing is LPLShortFormApp as I understand it (since the list of areas is a fixed list). if what you are doing feels like an update/edit/create i would stick with the default set of actions rather than create a set action

2. How do I collect/scrape each of the individual percentages from the form so that I can validate them against a total of 100%?

you're going to have to plough through the params hash. right now it will be bust since all of your form inputs have the same name (and so will overwrite each other). The form helpers guide (on guides.rubyonrails.org) has information on dealing with that sort of thing.

3. How do I take that collection and generate a new record in the practices table such that it joins the LPLSFA with the Practice Area? Each LPLSFA will have all 30 practice areas, so 30 practices records, most of which will probably be at a 0 percentage. I'm imagining something like this:

you're starting to get into the complex forms arena (ie a form that does not edit/update a single row in the database). one way of going it would be to have a method on LPLShortFormApp that took as an argument the info from the params and created the rows in the join table.

Fred

Ahad Amdani wrote:

Thanks for the assistance. I've been looking at the guides, and I found this in 7.3 of the forms guide:

<% form_for @person do |person_form| %>   <%= person_form.text_field :name %>   <% for address in @person.addresses %>   <% person_form.fields_for address, :index => address do >address_form|%>   <%= address_form.text_field :city %>   <% end %>   <% end %> <% end %>

I believe I can do something similar with @lpl_short_form_app.practices :slight_smile:

I'll try it out and report my results, for people who may be searching for similar results.

My resulting solution didn't actually have much to do with this - however, it doesn't take away any merits from this solution!

Good luck, and happy coding.